I’m Still Not That Girl
I’m Still Not That Girl is an award winning dark comedy about what happens when the life you thought you were supposed to have never quite shows up.
Jessica Lia Berry takes audiences from New York to Los Angeles, tracing a hilariously messy path through dating, heartbreak, bad decisions, and the impossible pressure to become the woman everyone expects you to be. Through sharp physical comedy, inventive use of props, audience interaction, and a rotating cast of unforgettable characters, Berry transforms the stage around her, blurring the line between confession, stand-up, and theatre.
Think Fleabag meets Sex and the City, but with grief lurking just beneath the punchlines.
At the center of the show is Jessica’s relationship with her late mother, whose voice and memory quietly reshape everything that came before. What begins as a comedy about dating and adulthood becomes something far more vulnerable: a story about losing the person who knew you best, realizing there may be no finish line to becoming “that girl,” and learning how to build a life anyway.
Fast, physical, intimate, irreverent, and unexpectedly moving, I’m Still Not That Girl is for anyone who has ever looked around at adulthood and thought, Wait… this is it?
Following a sold-out U.S. tour, a Best Festival Debut win at New York’s United Solo Festival, and an acclaimed run at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe, where it earned a five-star review from Broadway Baby, I’m Still Not That Girl is a fiercely personal comedy about heartbreak, grief, reinvention, and what happens when becoming yourself looks nothing like you thought it would.
Credits
Created, Written & Performed by
JESSICA LIA BERRY
Directed by
BAILEY NASSETTA
Stage Manager
NIKITA CERNIN
(Tour Feb 2026- April 2026)
Produced by
CURIOSITY KILLED THE CAT
Portland Playhouse — March 28, 2026.
Portland Playhouse — March 28, 2026.
Portland Playhouse — March 28, 2026.
Portland Playhouse — March 28, 2026.
Portland Playhouse — March 28, 2026.
Audience Reviews
“I’m Still Not That Girl is such a captivating show. It will truly reel you in with the storyline and interactive moments with the audience. Even the props and sound design were so well thought out to make the viewer experience even more compelling. Not only is it funny and relatable, it has a very powerful message throughout that ends on a deep, emotional level. It was very impressive to see all of the different characters so well played out by a one woman show. Definitely recommend!!”
Jen Smith
“I saw the show twice and I’m still not over it!!! “I’m Still Not That Girl” is like having a drink with your funniest, most brutally honest friend who also secretly has the vocal cords of a Broadway diva. It’s sharp, self aware, and somehow manages to roast modern dating, social media, and our collective therapy habits while still feeling weirdly hopeful. I laughed, I winced in recognition, and I left feeling slightly attacked but in the best possible way. If you’ve ever thought, Wait, wasn’t I supposed to have my life together by now? this show will make you feel seen, heard, and extremely entertained.”
Jason McNary
“A bold, modern play that explores sex, love, loss and the vulnerability to being a women today. The performance is magnetic and invites the audience into the complexities of her world - a must see.”
Shakir Najieb
“This show is a journey! Berry takes us on a rollercoaster through her twenties, the twists and turns of her relationships, the loops that sent her life upside down, and the times things nearly went off the tracks. Berry dances through the controlled chaos and ends on a beautifully poignant note.”
Elyse Emmerling (Edinburgh Fringe)
“From the beginning to the end,.. I was enthralled. Jessica's story coupled with her audience engagement is a true gift to experience. The beauty of her vulnerability is hilarious and at times heartbreaking. This piece and performance deserves a broader platform.”
Bobby Moynahan
“Jessica conveyed her tale brilliantly. She took us on a hilarious journey on the road of introspection. The actualization of the tale was very human and full of life despite the fact that she had to pull double duty for all of the roles. It made me wonder what Jessica could do with a production budget. I went there for inspiration from a new experience and she delivered. It just goes to show you that real art always shines the brightest. Can’t wait to see her future.”
Trevon Hughes
“This was an absolute must see play. Jessica did an amazing job on this one. She captured my attention and emotions from beginning to end. You will laugh, dance, and might even want to cry. Relatable for sure. Love it love it love it.”
Leslie Barton
“Masterful story telling engaging both with the audience and the content. What looks like a seemingly innocuous subject dating and validation takes a twist into some darker territory, expertly delivered with compelling characters. Thoroughly enjoyed this and I highly recommend.”
Ronnie Honey (Edinburgh Fringe)
“Went to an AMAZING show Tuesday, because we were flier-ed by JLB on Monday evening! Dark, funny, incredible characterization and perfectly timed humour. Adapted and adjusted to audiences' responses with ease and aplomb. Would recommend this poignant and wonderfully acted performance. Thanks JLB for coming all the way from LA!”
Ben (Edinburgh Fringe)
“Such a fun, enjoyable show! Jessica has crafted a genuinely refreshing and vulnerable exercise in grief and finding yourself in young adulthood - the show was full of raw, honest moments, both laugh-out-loud entertaining and emotionally touching, seamlessly interweaving dating stories many of us can relate to (or hope we never will) to serious issues of regret or losing someone.”
Lauren
“As a solo show performer myself, I truly value supporting artists who bring their work to Atlanta—and I’m so glad I came out to experience Jessica’s show. I actually discovered her through her promotional campaign, and I have to start there—her marketing is incredible. She clearly understands how to build momentum, create visibility, and most importantly, get people in the room. As an independent artist, that’s no small feat, and it’s something I deeply respect. What also stood out to me was the audience engagement. The crowd was fully tapped in, responsive, and along for the ride. That kind of connection doesn’t happen by accident—it takes intention, presence, and confidence in your work. Overall, it was a fabulous showing from an artist who clearly knows how to produce, promote, and create an experience that brings people together. Looking forward to seeing how her journey continues to expand.”
Valeka
“Jessica Lia Berry killed it. Laugh Out Loud Funny. Hope to see it as a one hour series very soon in the future to see it as a complete series with no cliffhanger. Netflix should pick it up and order it for the amount of episodes to complete it's series.”
Jarrell Curtis
“Great performance 👏🏾. It felt like I was with her from New York to LA and I was experiencing all the motions with her. Red shoes, red flag!!!! Watch the show and you’ll get it. 😅”
Rungano (Edinburgh Fringe)
“Loved the show. “Sica” has such great energy. She is a captivating performer. I do not even finish watching Tiktoks over 30s but she had my attention for a whole hour. Loved the story, the use of props, the engagement, the humour and the vibe. Grab your people and go watch !! Also just seems like a great person. :) Was my first fringe show. 10/10.”
Nancy (Edinburgh Fringe)